Alexander Povetkin had one of the longest reigns in the top three of any boxer in history—possibly the longest of any boxer who didn't reach the top. This month in our Top 100 rankings Povetkin, who retired in June, 2021, has just now slipped out of the top 10, ending a string of just shy of 15 years there. In all Povetkin spent 179 months in the top ten, with 107 months—nearly 9 years—at #3, with a full 12 years in the top five. Here's a rundown of his career in our top 10:
February 2008 rankings: Povetkin breaks into the top ten following a stellar 2007
2004 olympic gold medalist Povetkin's pro career got off to a good start at 10-0. He then had a great 2007, winning four fights over ranked fighters including an 11th round TKO of #6 Chris Byrd in the first fight of the IBF eliminator designed to pick Wlad Klitschko's next foe at the time. That put him at #11, just outside the top ten for three months before the IBF eliminator final vs. Eddie Chambers, which he won by unanimous decision on January 26, 2008. That put Povetkin not just in the top ten but in the top five, at #4.
June 2007 |
July 2007 |
Nov 2007 |
Jan 2008 |
Feb 2008 |
Fighter |
Rating
|
Rated Record | January 2008 results |
1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | WLAD KLITSCHKO | 21.42 | 27-3-0 | |
2 | 2 | 2 | 2 | 2 | RUSLAN CHAGAEV | 13.86 | 10-0-0 | UD 12 #8 MATT SKELTON |
4 | 4 | 3 | 3 | 3 | SAMUEL PETER | 7.53 | 14-1-0 | |
58 | 47 | 11 | 11 | 4 | ALEX POVETKIN | 7.20 | 10-0-0 | UD 12 #6 EDDIE CHAMBERS |
5 | 5 | 4 | 4 | 5 | NICOLAY VALUEV | 6.74 | 18-1-0 |
December 2009 rankings: Povetkin ascends to the #3 spot after David Haye beats #3 Nicolay Valuev in November
The promised fight with Klitschko didn't happen just yet. Povetkin's management felt he wasn't ready to face Wladimir (they were right) as he was only 28 and had plenty of time to develop. Povetkin won a few stay-busy fights that held his rank.
By this time Wladimir Klitschko had beaten #2 Chagaev, and Vitali Klitscho had beaten #3 Sam Peter and taken over the #2 spot with Nicolay Valuev then at #3. When David Haye beat Valuev, Povetkin moved into the #3 spot where he would camp literally for years.
Feb 2008 |
Aug 2008 |
May 2009 |
Nov 2009 |
Dec 2009 |
Fighter |
Rating
|
Rated Record | November 2009 results |
1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | WLAD KLITSCHKO | 59.13 | 31-3-0 | |
11 | 12 | 3 | 2 | 2 | VITALI KLITSCHKO | 37.21 | 20-2-0 | |
4 | 5 | 5 | 4 | 3 | ALEX POVETKIN | 29.08 | 12-0-0 | |
20 | 13 | 7 | 5 | 4 | EDDIE CHAMBERS | 26.76 | 13-1-0 | |
2 | 2 | 2 | 6 | 5 | RUSLAN CHAGAEV | 26.50 | 11-1-0 | |
59 | 64 | 23 | 21 | 6 | DAVID HAYE | 25.35 | 3-0-0 | MD 12 #3 NICOLAY VALUEV |
5 | 4 | 4 | 3 | 7 | NICOLAY VALUEV | 20.81 | 21-2-0 | L MD 12 #21 DAVID HAYE |
October 2013: Povetkin finally fights Wladimir Klitschko—and loses—but retains his #3 ranking in the November rankings
From late 2009 thru 2013 Povetkin won 8 fights, including a unanimous decision win over Ruslan Chagaev in August of 2011. Along with the Klitschko brothers who were also undefeated during that span, the top trio dominated boxing and were far ahead of the rest of the pack. So far ahead that when Povetkin fought Wlad Klitschko on October 5, 2013, and lost a lopsided decision, he remained at #3 in the November, 2013 rankings:
Jan 2010 |
Jan 2011 |
Jan 2012 |
Jan 2013 |
Oct 2013 |
Fighter |
Rating
|
Rated Record | 2013 Jan-Sept results |
1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | WLAD KLITSCHKO | 69.90 | 38-3-0 | TKO 6 #15 FRANCESCO PIANETA |
2 | 2 | 2 | 2 | 2 | VITALI KLITSCHKO | 46.76 | 27-2-0 | --last rated win -12 months. |
3 | 3 | 3 | 3 | 3 | ALEX POVETKIN | 39.27 | 20-0-0 | TKO 3 #17 ANDRZEJ WAWRZYK |
45 | 23 | 13 | 5 | 4 | KUBRAT PULEV | 26.67 | 12-0-0 | UD 12 #44 TONY THOMPSON |
71 | 63 | 4 | 4 | 5 | TYSON FURY | 24.48 | 11-0-0 | KO 7 #121 STEVE CUNNINGHAM |
Jan 2011 |
Jan 2012 |
Jan 2013 |
Oct 2013 |
Nov 2013 |
Fighter |
Rating
|
Rated Record | October 2013 results |
1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | WLAD KLITSCHKO | 75.22 | 39-3-0 | UD 12 #3 ALEX POVETKIN |
2 | 2 | 2 | 2 | 2 | VITALI KLITSCHKO | 46.27 | 27-2-0 | --last rated win -13 months. |
3 | 3 | 3 | 3 | 3 | ALEX POVETKIN | 27.76 | 20-1-0 | L UD 12 #1 WLAD KLITSCHKO |
23 | 13 | 5 | 4 | 4 | KUBRAT PULEV | 26.67 | 12-0-0 | |
63 | 4 | 4 | 5 | 5 | TYSON FURY | 24.48 | 11-0-0 |
October 2015 rankings: Alexander Povetkin moves to #2 as the retired Vitali Klitchko slides to #3
Following the loss to Klitschko, Povetkin beat Manuel Charr, Carlos Takam, and Mike Perez to maintain his #3 ranking. Meanwhile Vitali Klitschko had last fought in September of 2012 and had retired, losing rating points since late 2013. Finally in the October, 2015 rankings Klitschko slipped below Povetkin who was finally #2 after spending almost six years at #3!
June 2014 |
Nov 2014 |
June 2015 |
Sep 2015 |
Oct 2015 |
Fighter |
Rating
|
Rated Record | September 2015 results |
1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | WLAD KLITSCHKO | 79.15 | 42-3-0 | |
3 | 3 | 3 | 3 | 2 | ALEX POVETKIN | 32.53 | 23-1-0 | |
2 | 2 | 2 | 2 | 3 | VITALI KLITSCHKO | 32.36 | 27-2-0 | --last rated win -37 months. |
5 | 5 | 4 | 4 | 4 | TYSON FURY | 29.56 | 14-0-0 | |
7 | 6 | 5 | 5 | 5 | CZAR GLAZKOV | 24.60 | 10-0-1 |
November 2015 rankings: Unfortunately that was Alex's only month at #2.
The same month Povetkin rose to #2, #4 Tyson Fury upset Wladimir Klitschko. This pushed Klitschko to #2, and Povetkin back to #3, despite a win over Mariusz Wach.
Nov 2014 |
June 2015 |
Sep 2015 |
Oct 2015 |
Nov 2015 |
Fighter |
Rating
|
Rated Record | October 2015 results |
5 | 4 | 4 | 4 | 1 | TYSON FURY | 63.29 | 15-0-0 | UD 12 #1 WLAD KLITSCHKO |
1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 2 | WLAD KLITSCHKO | 55.96 | 42-4-0 | L UD 12 #4 TYSON FURY |
3 | 3 | 3 | 2 | 3 | ALEX POVETKIN | 32.71 | 24-1-0 | TKO 12 #145 MARIUSZ WACH |
2 | 2 | 2 | 3 | 4 | VITALI KLITSCHKO | 31.65 | 27-2-0 | --last rated win -38 months. |
6 | 5 | 5 | 5 | 5 | CZAR GLAZKOV | 24.60 | 10-0-1 |
January 2017 rankings: Povetkin takes over as interim champion!
Despite remaining #3 for all of 2016, Povetkin became champ in early 2017 after beating Johann Duhaupas. With Fury and Klitschko's rematch postponed (and eventually cancelled) both Fury and Klitschko fell into inactivity, as did Povetkin. That left the interim belt with #4 Deontay Wilder for a month, before Povetkin's win re-established him as an active fighter.
The fight with Duhaupas happened after Povetkin's PED drama unfolded over 2016. Originally pitted against Deontay Wilder in June, that fight was cancelled when Povetkin tested positive for Meldonium, a substance only recently banned. Povetkin was scheduled against Bermane Stiverne but tested positive for Ostarine, and Stiverne refused to fight; Duhaupas was a last-minute replacement.
Nov 2015 |
Feb 2016 |
Aug 2016 |
Dec 2016 |
Jan 2017 |
Fighter |
Rating
|
Rated Record | December 2016 results |
1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | TYSON FURY | 61.99 | 15-0-0 | --last rated win -13 months. |
2 | 2 | 2 | 2 | 2 | WLAD KLITSCHKO | 50.56 | 42-4-0 | --last rated win -20 months. |
3 | 3 | 3 | 3 | 3 | ALEX POVETKIN | 33.51 | 25-1-0 | KO 6 #18 JOHANN DUHAUPAS [new interim title holder] |
6 | 5 | 4 | 4 | 4 | DEONTAY WILDER | 27.26 | 13-0-0 | |
22 | 15 | 5 | 5 | 5 | ANTHONY JOSHUA | 26.33 | 11-0-0 | TKO 3 #78 ERIC MOLINA |
May 2017 rankings: Povetkin drops out of top 3 after 7 years and 5 months
Povetkin held the SportsRatings Interim Heavyweight Title for four months. In May, After 7 years and 5 months in the top 3, Povetkin dropped to #4 following Anthony Joshua's win over Wlad Klitschko. Again Klitschko stayed above Povetkin in the rankings at #3, pushing Alex to #4. Therefore, Povetkin's official dates of holding the interim belt were from December 17, 2016 to April 29, 2017, about 4 1/2 months.
Jan 2017 |
Feb 2017 |
Mar 2017 |
Apr 2017 |
May 2017 |
Fighter |
Rating
|
Rated Record | April 2017 results |
1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | TYSON FURY | 59.29 | 15-0-0 | --last rated win -17 months. |
5 | 5 | 5 | 5 | 2 | ANTHONY JOSHUA | 42.94 | 12-0-0 | TKO 11 #2 WLAD KLITSCHKO [new interim title holder] |
2 | 2 | 2 | 2 | 3 | WLAD KLITSCHKO | 33.92 | 42-5-0 | L TKO 11 #5 ANTHONY JOSHUA |
3 | 3 | 3 | 3 | 4 | ALEX POVETKIN | 33.51 | 25-1-0 | |
4 | 4 | 4 | 4 | 5 | DEONTAY WILDER | 28.69 | 14-0-0 |
June 2017 rankings: Povetkin back in the top three!
It seemed that nothing would keep Alex Povetkin out of the #3 spot. Not losing to Klitschko, not ascending to #2, and not falling to #4. Because the month after he was pushed out of the top 3 he was right back in as Wlad Klitschko dropped to #4 due to his extended time without a rated win. Povetkin had finally passed Klitschko—not from beating him in the ring, but by outlasting him at the top.
Feb 2017 |
Mar 2017 |
Apr 2017 |
May 2017 |
June 2017 |
Fighter |
Rating
|
Rated Record | May 2017 results |
1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | TYSON FURY | 58.60 | 15-0-0 | --last rated win -18 months. |
5 | 5 | 5 | 2 | 2 | ANTHONY JOSHUA | 42.94 | 12-0-0 | [Interim title holder] |
3 | 3 | 3 | 4 | 3 | ALEX POVETKIN | 33.51 | 25-1-0 | |
2 | 2 | 2 | 3 | 4 | WLAD KLITSCHKO | 33.44 | 42-5-0 | --last rated win -25 months. |
4 | 4 | 4 | 5 | 5 | DEONTAY WILDER | 28.69 | 14-0-0 |
October 2018 rankings: Povetkin falls out of top three (for good?)
Povetkin beat Andrey Rudenko, Christian Hammer, and David Price over the next year to set up a big fight with Anthony Joshua in Wembley Stadium for Joshua's WBA and IBF belts, as well as the SportsRatings Heavyweight Title. Povetkin lost to Joshua via 7th round TKO, his 2nd loss and his first by stoppage. He fell to #4, and it looked like his long reign in the top 3—now 104 total months over the last 8 years—was over. Joshua captured the outright SportsRatings title for the first time, something Povetkin would never do.
July 2017 |
Dec 2017 |
Mar 2018 |
Sep 2018 |
Oct 2018 |
Fighter |
Rating
|
Rated Record | September 2018 results |
2 | 2 | 2 | 2 | 1 | ANTHONY JOSHUA | 53.28 | 15-0-0 | TKO 7 #3 ALEX POVETKIN |
1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 2 | TYSON FURY | 47.88 | 16-0-0 | |
5 | 4 | 4 | 4 | 3 | DEONTAY WILDER | 33.39 | 16-0-0 | |
3 | 3 | 3 | 3 | 4 | ALEX POVETKIN | 25.53 | 28-2-0 | L TKO 7 #2 ANTHONY JOSHUA |
4 | 5 | 5 | 5 | 5 | WLAD KLITSCHKO | 24.64 | 42-5-0 | --last rated win -41 months. |
January 2021 rankings: Back in the top three!
Over the next two years Povetkin fell as low as #6, and he remained there after a draw vs. Michael Hunter. But in August of 2020 he knocked out #5 Dillian Whyte, and with the help of inactivity by Deontay Wilder (after his loss to Tyson Fury) Povetkin was back in the top three again.
July 2019 |
Aug 2019 |
Sep 2020 |
Dec 2020 |
Jan 2021 |
Fighter |
Rating
|
Rated Record | December 2020 results |
1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | TYSON FURY | 53.79 | 18-0-1 | |
4 | 4 | 2 | 2 | 2 | ANTHONY JOSHUA | 47.27 | 17-1-0 | KO 9 #6 KUBRAT PULEV |
5 | 6 | 4 | 4 | 3 | ALEX POVETKIN | 28.60 | 30-2-1 | |
3 | 3 | 3 | 3 | 4 | DEONTAY WILDER | 28.41 | 18-1-1 | --last rated win -13 months. |
2 | 2 | 5 | 5 | 5 | ANDY RUIZ JR | 25.82 | 13-2-0 | --last rated win -18 months. |
April 2021 rankings: Out of the top three for good
Povetkin had a rough time after the first Dillian Whyte fight on August 22. He had to pull out of the rematch scheduled for November 21 due to having Covid, and it was eventually rescheduled for March 27, 2021. A lackluster Povetkin didn't look like himself at all and lost via 4th round TKO. He announced his retirement on June 13.
Sep 2020 |
Dec 2020 |
Jan 2021 |
Mar 2021 |
Apr 2021 |
Fighter |
Rating
|
Rated Record | March 2021 results |
1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | TYSON FURY | 52.68 | 18-0-1 | --last rated win -13 months. |
2 | 2 | 2 | 2 | 2 | ANTHONY JOSHUA | 47.27 | 17-1-0 | [Interim title holder] |
3 | 3 | 4 | 4 | 3 | DEONTAY WILDER | 27.48 | 18-1-1 | --last rated win -16 months. |
10 | 9 | 8 | 10 | 4 | DILLIAN WHYTE | 26.35 | 14-2-0 | TKO 4 #3 ALEX POVETKIN |
5 | 5 | 5 | 5 | 5 | ANDY RUIZ JR | 24.88 | 13-2-0 | --last rated win -21 months. |
4 | 4 | 3 | 3 | 6 | ALEX POVETKIN | 20.22 | 30-3-1 | L TKO 4 #10 DILLIAN WHYTE |
January 2023 rankings: Out of the top ten—first time since January 2008
Povetkin's long run in the top ten comes to an end as he slides out due to inactivity. The SportsRatings rankings don't look at whether a fighter is "retired" or not, just whether he's been fighting, so Povetkin started losing points in September of 2021 (his last win was August of 2020).
Apr 2021 |
Oct 2021 |
June 2022 |
Sep 2022 |
Jan 2023 |
Fighter |
Rating
|
Rated Record | Sept-Dec 2022 results |
1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | TYSON FURY | 55.93 | 21-0-1 | TKO 10 #59 DEREK CHISORA |
26 | 2 | 2 | 2 | 2 | OLEKSANDR USYK | 41.55 | 4-0-0 | |
5 | 6 | 4 | 3 | 3 | ANDY RUIZ JR | 24.54 | 15-2-0 | UD 12 #38 LUIS ORTIZ |
7 | 8 | 6 | 6 | 4 | JOE JOYCE | 22.29 | 10-0-0 | KO 11 #7 JOSEPH PARKER |
11 | 11 | 5 | 5 | 5 | FRANK SANCHEZ | 21.07 | 7-0-0 | TKO 9 #97 CARLOS NEGRON |
2 | 3 | 3 | 4 | 6 | ANTHONY JOSHUA | 20.26 | 17-3-0 | --last rated win -24 months. |
4 | 4 | 8 | 8 | 7 | DILLIAN WHYTE | 17.99 | 15-3-0 | MD 10 #62 JERMAINE FRANKLIN |
3 | 5 | 11 | 14 | 8 | DEONTAY WILDER | 17.83 | 19-2-1 | KO 1 #17 ROBERT HELENIUS |
18 | 14 | 13 | 9 | 9 | JUSTIS HUNI | 17.37 | 4-0-0 | UD 10 #190 KIKI TOA LEUTELE |
19 | 19 | 10 | 11 | 10 | ZHAN KOSSOBUTSKIY | 16.58 | 6-0-0 | KO 3 #91 HUSSEIN MUHAMED |
6 | 7 | 9 | 10 | 11 | ALEX POVETKIN | 16.34 | 30-3-1 | --last rated win -28 months. |
After Trouncing Haye, Does Wladimir Klitschko Belong in the All-Time Top 10?
Now the hype is over, and a fight that appeared to be interesting for several rounds lulled into another anticlimactic affair. Wladimir Klitschko emerged victorious yet again and further cemented his position at the top of the heavyweight division.
But where should he rank on the all-time list of heavyweight boxers? There seem to be two schools of though, as polarized as the opinions about both Klitschko brothers.
On one hand you have those who think that the heavyweight division is depleted and shallow, perhaps at an all-time low. With no sound competition, it's only natural that one (or two) decent fighters dominate the scene, even if they would be B-level fighters in any other era. Citing Wladimir's three embarrassing knockout losses to less-than-great fighters, they argue that he doesn't belong in the all-time top 50.
Others, however, point to Wladimir's complete dominance of his title fights recently, wherein he has nearly pitched shutouts across the board. Other respected heavies (Holmes and Tyson, for example, in the 80s, and even Louis and Marciano) spent the majority of their reigns beating fighters that don't show up on anyone's all-time best lists. Wladimir has been unchallenged for over half a decade, which ranks with the best. Further, they argue, boxing has never seen the likes of the Klitschkos, who are super-heavies and size and height, and with their weight and reach advantage, they could arguably beat any fighter who ever lived; perhaps, then, Wladimir Klitschko should be at or near #1 on the all-time list.
By our all-time rankings formula, Wladimir Klitschko has moved—for the first time—into the top ten. His five-year string of wins over top ten foes has helped him amass enough points to pass the likes of George Foreman, Sonny Liston, and Jersey Joe Walcott in the last year.
SportsRatings All-Time Heavyweight Top 10 (click here for full Top 500)
Rank
Rating
highest-rated win
win: 9/1978 UD 15 #42 LEON SPINKS
win: 9/1952 KO 13 #10 JERSEY JOE WALCOT
win: 6/1938 KO 1 #21 MAX SCHMELING
win: 10/1980 KO 11 #1 MUHAMMAD ALI
win: 6/1988 KO 1 #19 MICHAEL SPINKS
win: 9/1950 UD 15 #3 JOE LOUIS
win: 11/1999 UD 12 #13 EVANDER HOLYFIELD
win: 8/1954 KO 14 #22 HAROLD JOHNSON
win: 6/2009 KO 9 #199 RUSLAN CHAGAEV
win: 7/1951 KO 7 #6 EZZARD CHARLES
Still a long, long way away from reaching Muhammed Ali at the top spot (or #2 Marciano and #3 Louis), Klitschko is within striking distance of reaching the top 5, and could pass Lennox Lewis with another win or two.
No formula, of course, is going to ring "true" in all cases, and in Klitschko's case any ranking, period, is unsatisfying. Without worthy competition, a fighter can't prove he's one of the all-time greats. But dominating in any era should be worth something. What, then, is the best balance?
Klitschko has defeated many of the better fighters of the current era, and without breaking much of a sweat in most cases. But most observers wouldn't rank these fighters very highly on an all-time scale, and our system bears this out. Here is a look at Wladimir's career and the contemporary (time of fight) and all-time ranking for each opponent:
Date Result Rankings Opponent
12/1998: LOSS by KO to #101 #1051 ROSS PURITTY
05/1999: Win by KO over #114 #2257 TONY LAROSA
09/1999: Win by KO over #84 #590 AXEL SCHULZ
11/1999: Win by KO over #201 #499 PHIL JACKSON
12/1999: Win by KO over #66 #3050 LAJOS EROS
03/2000: Win by KO over #42 #1127 PAEA WOLFGRAMM
04/2000: Win by KO over #45 #510 DAVID BOSTICE
07/2000: Win by KO over #47 #390 MONTE BARRETT
10/2000: Win by UD over #7 #146 CHRIS BYRD
03/2001: Win by KO over #113 #713 DERRICK JEFFERSON
08/2001: Win by KO over #61 #746 CHARLES SHUFFORD
03/2002: Win by KO over #90 #356 FRANS BOTHA
06/2002: Win by KO over #99 #238 RAY MERCER
12/2002: Win by KO over #6 #303 JAMEEL MCCLINE
03/2003: LOSS by KO to #88 #247 CORRIE SANDERS
08/2003: Win by KO over #53 #456 FABIO MOLI
12/2003: Win by KO over #116 #458 DANELL NICHOLSON
04/2004: LOSS by KO to #75 #321 LAMON BREWSTER
10/2004: Win by TDW over #16 #317 DAVARL WILLIAMSON
04/2005: Win by KO over #50 #2558 ELISEO CASTILLO
09/2005: Win by UD over #5 #184 SAMUEL PETER
04/2006: Win by KO over #2 #146 CHRIS BYRD
11/2006: Win by KO over #8 #355 CALVIN BROCK
03/2007: Win by KO over #30 #281 RAY AUSTIN
07/2007: Win by KO over #17 #321 LAMON BREWSTER
02/2008: Win by UD over #9 #601 SULTAN IBRAGIMOV
07/2008: Win by KO over #7 #196 TONY THOMPSON
12/2008: Win by KO over #13 #98 HASIM RAHMAN
06/2009: Win by KO over #2 #199 RUSLAN CHAGAEV
03/2010: Win by KO over #4 #285 EDDIE CHAMBERS
09/2010: Win by KO over #12 #184 SAMUEL PETER
07/2011: Win by UD over #4 #697 DAVID HAYE
As you can see, he has a string of wins over top 10 foes—10 in all counting Haye—but he's beaten only one fighter in the All-Time top 100, Hasim Rahman (who wasn't in the top ten at the time). Further, Klitschko lost to three low-rated fighters, including Ross Puritty who is only #1,051 by our system!
Early losses by fighters tend to be forgiven, and our system concentrates on wins. Klitschko is clearly a different fighter than he was when he lost to Puritty, Sanders, and Brewster. And the all-time rankings of the boxers he's defeated will go up as their careers continue, so Wlad's resumé won't always look so paltry.
Still, it's telling to compare to an era when big matchups were commonplace. When George Foreman beat Joe Frazier, Joltin' Joe was not only ranked #1, but he was already in the all-time top 10. Likewise, Foreman was in the all-time top ten when Ali beat him. Compare that to Wlad's most-hyped fight, where David Haye is not in the top 500, and to his highest-rated win, over all-time #199 Ruslan Chagaev.
Suffice it to say, there's a reason these fights didn't capture the public's imagination like boxing did in the 1970's, and it goes beyond the fact that, to fans the United States, these men are all foreigners (though that plays a part). It also goes beyond the widely-held view that Klitschkos fights aren't very exciting (though that also plays a part). For fans to really be engaged, there has to be competition, and for a fighter to truly earn respect, he needs a worthy foe.
Right now there is only one fighter who could challenge Wladimir Klitschko, and that is his brother Vitali.
It would be a great fight, on par with any in boxing history, but it will never happen. When people debate Wlad's all-time rank, they also debate his current rank, as many feel Vitali is the better boxer. Vitali, however, ranks only #33 on our all-time list. Why? Here's a look at his relevant resumé:
Date Result Rankings Opponent
10/1998: Win by KO over #87 #961 MARIO SCHIESSER
06/1999: Win by KO over #12 #223 HERBIE HIDE
10/1999: Win by KO over #15 #546 ED MAHONE
12/1999: Win by KO over #180 #511 OBED SULLIVAN
04/2000: LOSS by KO to #25 #146 CHRIS BYRD
11/2000: Win by UD over #24 #301 TIMO HOFFMAN
01/2001: Win by KO over #147 #170 ORLIN NORRIS
12/2001: Win by KO over #125 #1051 ROSS PURITTY
02/2002: Win by KO over #149 #1719 VAUGHN BEAN
11/2002: Win by KO over #37 #187 LARRY DONALD
06/2003: LOSS by KO to #1 #7 LENNOX LEWIS
12/2003: Win by KO over #17 #252 KIRK JOHNSON
04/2004: Win by KO over #5 #247 CORRIE SANDERS
12/2004: Win by KO over #14 #176 DANNY WILLIAMS
10/2008: Win by KO over #3 #184 SAMUEL PETER
03/2009: Win by KO over #7 #411 JUAN C GOMEZ
09/2009: Win by KO over #6 #225 CHRIS ARREOLA
12/2009: Win by UD over #28 #662 KEVIN JOHNSON
05/2010: Win by KO over #16 #540 ALBERT SOSNOWSKI
10/2010: Win by UD over #96 #200 SHANNON BRIGGS
03/2011: Win by KO over #10 #681 ODLANIER SOLIS
Two things stand out. One, Vitali has far fewer wins over top 10 opponents (just 5), and two, he took four years off from fighting during his prime. Both of these will do quite a bit of harm to his standing in any algorithmic, point-based system. The level of respect Vitali has from the boxing community—generally greater than that afforded to Wladimir—comes from his loss to all-time great Lennox Lewis, wherein Vitali had Lewis in big trouble before succumbing to a doctor's stoppage. This fight alone overshadows anything else either brother has accomplished.
But in our system, unfortunately, it just goes down as a loss. Without many big wins, and four years off that lowered his peak score due to inactivity, Vitali doesn't measure up to Wlad, even if he may be the better boxer. He doesn't hold a win over anyone ranked in our all-time top 150.
All of this shows how difficult it is to place both brothers in boxing history in an unbiased way. Are they the culmination of decades of refinement of nutrition, technique, and training? Or are they flukes, freaks of nature who would be exposed in a different era? And without these two greats battling each other, how can we tell for sure who deserves to be ranked ahead of the other, let alone against other fighters?
No one has the answer. But in my personal opinion, I think both Klitschkos are all-time greats. Vitali proved himself against Lennox Lewis, and Wladimir has accomplished more in terms of winning than Vitali. Without great competition, I don't know if they'll ever be considered among the very best. Maybe if they fought, the victor could take his place among the Alis, Lewises, and Marcianos of the world, but since that will never happen, the Klitschkos will probably remain a double question mark. Great, but not the greatest.
Posted at 07:51 PM in Career overviews, Commentary, Heavyweight Boxing Top 100 | Permalink | Comments (0)